Facebook Twitter
MUFC Logo

NEWTON HEATH & MANCHESTER UNITED
OUTFIELD PLAYERS NEVER TO SCORE

This page is dedicated to all outfield Newton Heath or Manchester United players who made one or more first team appearance and failed to score.

Click on players name for profile
Outfield players never to score query
No Portrait Player Name Position National Flag Nationality Years at Club Games without scoring
1
Moore, Charlie full-back
England 1919-1921, 1922-1931 328
2
Jones, Thomas (1924-1937) full-back
Wales 1924-1937 200
3
Mellor, Jack full-back
England 1930-1937 122
4
Donaghy, Mal defender
Northern Ireland 1988-1992 119
5
Holden, Richard full-back
England 1904-1914 117
6
Gibson, Thomas half-back
England 1950-1955 115
7
Perrins, George right-half
England 1892-1896 102
8
Whitefoot, Jeffery half-back
England 1949-1956 95
9
Roughton, William full-back
England 1936-1939 92
10
Greaves, Ian full-back
England 1953-1960 75
11
Carolan, Joseph full-back
Republic of Ireland 1958-1960 71
12
Dale, William full-back
England 1928-1931 68
13
O'Neil, Thomas full-back
England 1970-1973 68
14
Porter, William full-back
England 1934-1944 65
15
Mitchell, Andrew (1892-1894) right-back
Scotland 1892-1894 61
16
McNulty, Thomas full-back
England 1949-1954 60
17
Linkson, Oscar full-back
England 1908-1913 59
18
Burgess, Herbert full-back
England 1906-1910 54
19
Garton, Billy defender
England 1983-1990 51
20
Spencer, Charles half-back
England 1928-1930 48
21
Malacia, Tyrell defender
Holland 2022-Present* 47
22
Clements, John left-back
England 1890-1894 42
23
Read, Thomas full-back
England 1902-1908 42
24
Blackstock, Thomas full-back
Scotland 1903-1907 38
25
Whalley, Bert half-back
England 1935-1947 38
26
Redman, William full-back
England 1950-1954 38
27
Donnelly, Anthony full-back
England 1908-1913 37
28
Tuanzebe, Axel defender
England 2017-2023 37
29
Forster, Thomas half-back
England 1916-1922 36
30
Mazraoui, Noussair defender
Morocco 2024-Present* 36
31
Noble, Bobby full-back
England 1965-1967 33
32
Fitzsimmons, David right-half
Scotland 1895-1896, 1899-1900 31
33
Hodge, John defender
Scotland 1913-1919 30
34
Barlow, Cyril full-back
England 1919-1923 30
35
Ferguson, Darren midfielder
Scotland 1990-1994 30
36
Fosu-Mensah, Timothy defender/midfielder
Holland 2014-2021 30
37
Amrabat, Sofyan midfielder
Morocco 2023-2024 30
38
Ugarte, Manuel midfielder
Uruguay 2024-Present* 29
39
Rothwell, Herbert full-back
England 1902-1903 28
40
Wallwork, Ronnie midfielder
England 1996-2004 28
41
Haslam, George half-back
England 1921-1927 27
42
Winterbottom, Walter half-back
England 1936-1938 27
43
Greening, Jonathan forward
England 1998-2002 27
44
McNair, Paddy defender
Northern Ireland 2014-2016 27
45
Haywood, Joseph half-back
England 1913-1915 26
46
Chapman, William forward
England 1926-1928 26
47
Pellistri, Facundo forward
Uruguay 2020-2024 25
48
Scott, John half-back
Scotland 1921-1922 24
49
Clegg, Michael defender
England 1996-2003 24
50
Gipps, Thomas half-back
England 1910-1920 23
51
Walton, Joseph W. half-back
England 1945-1948 23
52
Ball, John full-back
England 1947-1950 23
53
Morgans, Kenny forward
Wales 1957-1959 23
54
Jackson, Thomas midfielder
Northern Ireland 1975-1978 23
55
Crowther, Stan half-back
England 1957-1959 20
56
Sidebottom, Arnie half-back
England 1972-1975 20
57
Hofton, Leslie full-back
England 1910-1913, 1919-1922 19
58
Curtis, John full-back
England 1995-2000 19
59
Bardsley, Phil defender
Scotland 2003-2008 18
60
Smith, William inside-right
England 1901-1902 17
61
Parker, Thomas half-back
England 1930-1932 17
62
Chong, Tahith forward
Holland 2016-2022 16
63
Yoro, Leny defender
France 2024-Present* 16
64
Curry, Joseph half-back
England 1908-1911 14
65
Lowrie, Thomas half-back
Scotland 1947-1951 14
66
Watson, Willie full-back
Scotland 1970-1973 14
67
Thornley, Ben Forward
England 1993-1999 14
68
Stewart, Michael midfielder
Scotland 1997-2004 14
69
Borthwick-Jackson, Cameron defender
England 2015-2020 14
70
Cookson, Sam half-back
Wales 1914-1919 13
71
Spratt, Walter full-back
England 1915-1920 13
72
McCrae, James half-back
Scotland 1926 13
73
Lynn, Samuel half-back
England 1938-1951 13
74
Anderson, William forward
England 1963-1967 13
75
Parker, Samuel forward
Scotland 1894 12
76
Dunn, William forward
England 1897-1898 12
77
Allman, Arthur full-back
England 1914-1919 12
78
Gibson, Richard forward
England 1921-1922 12
79
Hannaford, Charles forward
England 1925-1927 12
80
Page, Louis forward
England 1931-1933 12
81
Bent, Geoff full-back
England 1954-1958 12
82
Kopel, Frank full-back
Scotland 1967-1969 12
83
Sloan, Thomas midfielder
Northern Ireland 1978-1982 12
84
Blackett, Tyler defender
England 2014-2016 12
85
Reguilon, Sergio defender
Spain 2023-2024 12
86
Hudson, Edward full-back
England 1912-1919 11
87
Ellis, David forward
Scotland 1923-1924 11
88
Harrop, Robert half-back
England 1954-1959 11
89
Varela, Guillermo defender
Uruguay 2013-2017 11
90
Higgins, William Alexander "Sandy" half-back
England 1901-1902 10
91
Brett, Frank full-back
England 1921-1922 10
92
Robinson, Matthew forward
England 1931-1932 10
93
Davies, Ronald "Tudor" forward
Wales 1974-1975 10
94
Paterson, Steven defender
Scotland 1974-1980 10
95
Wilson, Mark midfielder
England 1998-2001 10
96
Gomes, Angel forward
England 2016-2020 10
97
Kambwala, Willy defender
France 2020-2024 10
98
Erentz, Henry "Harry" right-back
Scotland 1897-1898 9
99
Clark, Joseph inside-right/outside-left
Scotland 1899-1900 9
100
Wilkinson, Henry "Harry" Forward
England 1903-1904, 1906 9
101
McGillivray, Charles forward
Scotland 1933-1934 9
102
Collyer, Toby midfielder
England 2022-Present* 9
103
Pepper, Francis "Frank" centre-half
England 1898-1899 8
104
Heathcote, Joseph forward
England 1899-1902 8
105
Gaudie, Ralph forward
England 1903 8
106
Higgins, Mark defender
England 1985-1987 8
107
Maiorana, Guiliano forward
England 1989-1994 8
108
Spector, Jonathon defender
USA 2003-2006 8
109
Simpson, Danny defender
England 2007-2010 8
110
Possebon, Rodrigo midfielder
Brazil 2008-2010 8
111
Brown, James (1892-1893) left-back
Scotland 1892-1893 7
112
Stone, Herbert centre-half
England 1893-1895 7
113
Fletcher, Peter forward
England 1972-1974 7
114
Griffiths, Clive defender
Wales 1973-1976 7
115
O'Kane, John defender
England 1994-1997 7
116
Casper, Chris defender
England 1993-1998 7
117
Higginbotham, Danny defender
England 1996-2000 7
118
Pugh, Danny midfielder
England 2000-2004 7
119
Garner, James midfielder
England 2017-2022 7
120
Forson, Omari midfielder
England 2020-2024 7
121
Owen, John "Jack" left-half
Wales 1887-1893 6
122
Henrys, Arthur half-back/outside-left
England 1891-1893 6
123
Sawyer, Thomas outside-right
England 1899-1901 6
124
Marshall, Arthur full-back
England 1903 6
125
Worrall, Harold full-back
England 1946-1948 6
126
Haydock, Frank half-back
England 1959-1963 6
127
Donald, Ian full-back
Scotland 1969-1973 6
128
Wilson, David midfielder
England 1988-1991 6
129
de Laet, Ritchie defender
Belgium 2009-2012 6
130
Fryers, Ezekiel defender
England 2011-2012 6
131
Lyons, George forward
England 1904-1906 5
132
Ford, Joseph forward
England 1907-1910 5
133
Nevin, George full-back
England 1933-1934 5
134
Savage, Robert half-back
England 1937-1938 5
135
Mulryne, Philip midfielder
Northern Ireland 1997-1999 5
136
Jones, Ritchie midfielder
England 2005-2008 5
137
Tosic, Zoran Forward
Serbia 2009-2010 5
138
Keane, Michael defender
England 2011-2014 5
139
Shoretire, Shola forward
England 2020-2024 5
140
Powell, John full-back
Wales 1886-1890 4
141
Graham, John centre-forward/centre-half
Scotland 1893-1894 4
142
Turner, John centre-half
England 1898-1903 4
143
Connachan, James forward
Scotland 1898-1899 4
144
Williams, William "Bill" inside-right/outside-right
England 1901 4
145
Ball, William half-back
England 1902-1903 4
146
Hartwell, William forward
England 1904-1905 4
147
Thomson, Ernest half-back
England 1906-1909 4
148
McGillivray, John half-back
England 1908-1910 4
149
Hulme, Aaron full-back
England 1906-1909 4
150
Hardman, Harold forward
England 1908-1909 4
151
Chorlton, Thomas full-back
England 1912-1914 4
152
Howarth, John full-back
England 1921-1923 4
153
Bain, James (1922-1928) half-back
Scotland 1922-1928 4
154
Ferguson, Daniel forward
Wales 1927-1928 4
155
Murray, Robert forward
Scotland 1937-1938 4
156
Dougan, Thomas forward
Scotland 1939-1940 4
157
Cassidy, Laurence forward
England 1947-1956 4
158
Buchan, George forward
Scotland 1972-1973 4
159
Bielby, Paul forward
England 1972-1976 4
160
Waldron, Colin defender
England 1976-1978 4
161
Wood, Nicky Forward
England 1985-1989 4
162
Nardiello, Daniel forward
Wales 1999-2005 4
163
Jones, David (2004-2007) midfielder
England 2004-2007 4
164
Campbell, Fraizer forward
England 2007-2009 4
165
Eckersley, Richard defender
England 2008-2009 4
166
Wootton, Scott defender
England 2012-2013 4
167
Zaha, Wilfred Forward
Ivory Coast 2013-2015 4
168
Wheatley, Ethan Forward
England 2022-Present* 4
169
Mitchell, John full-back
England 1885-1888, 1888-1891 3
170
McFarlane, Robert right-back
Scotland 1891-1892 3
171
Thomson, William inside-right
Scotland 1893 3
172
Whitney, John left-back/left-half
England 1895-1903 3
173
Lawson, Reginald "Reg" inside-right
England 1900 3
174
Greenwood, Wilson outside-left
England 1900-1901 3
175
Street, Ernest forward
England 1902-1904 3
176
Robertson, Thomas forward
Scotland 1903 3
177
Donaghy, Bernard forward
Ireland 1905-1906 3
178
Yates, William Forward
England 1906-1907 3
179
Buckley, Franklin half-back
England 1906-1907 3
180
Cashmore, Arthur forward
England 1913-1914 3
181
Lyner, David forward
Northern Ireland 1922 3
182
Cartman, Herbert forward
England 1922-1923 3
183
Lievesley, Wilfred forward
England 1922-1923 3
184
Dennis, William full-back
England 1923-1924 3
185
Hall, John "Jack" (1925-1927) forward
England 1925-1927 3
186
Williams, Frank half-back
England 1930-1931 3
187
Lydon, George half-back
England 1928-1933 3
188
Scott, John "Jackie" forward
England 1951-1956 3
189
Heron, Thomas forward
Scotland 1958-1961 3
190
Foggon, Alan forward
England 1976-1977 3
191
Healy, David forward
Northern Ireland 1999-2001 3
192
Webber, Danny Forward
England 1998-2002 3
193
Roche, Lee defender
England 2001-2003 3
194
Martin, Lee Robert midfielder
England 2005-2009 3
195
Dong, Fangzhou forward
China 2004-2008 3
196
Manucho forward
Angola 2008-2009 3
197
Morrison, Ravel midfielder
England 2010-2012 3
198
Keane, William "Will" forward
England 2011-2016 3
199
Davies, Joseph centre-half
Wales 1886-1890 2
200
Sharpe, William inside-left
England 1890-1891 2
201
Prince, S outside-left
England 1893-1894 2
202
Jones, John "Owen" forward
Wales 1898 2
203
Turner, Robert "Bob" defender
England 1898-1899 2
204
Walker, Robert centre-half
Scotland 1899 2
205
Blackmore, Peter centre-forward
England 1899 2
206
Booth, William outside-left
England 1900-1902 2
207
Bunce, William full-back
England 1902-1903 2
208
Kerr, Hugh forward
Scotland 1903-1904 2
209
Schofield, Joseph forward
England 1903-1905 2
210
Young, Arthur midfielder/defender
Scotland 1906-1907 2
211
Christie, David forward
Scotland 1907-1910 2
212
Quin, Jack forward
Scotland 1908-1911 2
213
Roberts, Robert full-back
England 1913-1919 2
214
Williamson, John half-back
England 1920-1921 2
215
Pugh, James full-back
England 1921-1923 2
216
Iddon. Richard forward
England 1925-1927 2
217
Astley, John "Joe" full-back
England 1925-1928 2
218
Haworth, Ronald forward
England 1926-1927 2
219
Dean, Harold forward
England 1931 2
220
Lievesley, Leslie half-back
England 1932-1933 2
221
Manns, Thomas half-back
England 1934 2
222
Newton, Percy half-back
England 1931-1934 2
223
Ainsworth, Alfred forward
England 1933-1934 2
224
Roach, John full-back
England 1946 2
225
Dale, Joseph forward
England 1947-1948 2
226
McIlvenny, Edward half-back
USA 1950-1953 2
227
Walton, John Forward
England 1951-1952 2
228
Baldwin, Thomas midfielder
England 1974-1975 2
229
Grimshaw, Anthony defender
England 1975-1979 2
230
Connell, Thomas full-back
Northern Ireland 1978-1982 2
231
Dempsey, Mark midfielder
England 1982-1986 2
232
Brazil, Derek defender
Republic of Ireland 1986-1992 2
233
Wratten, Paul midfielder
England 1991-1992 2
234
Tomlinson, Greame Forward
England 1994-1998 2
235
Prunier, William defender
France 1995-1996 2
236
Appleton, Michael midfielder
England 1996-1997 2
237
Twiss, Michael Forward
England 1996-2000 2
238
Djordjic, Bojan midfielder
Sweden 1999-2004 2
239
Shawcross, Ryan defender
England 2006-2008 2
240
King, Joshua forward
Norway 2009-2013 2
241
Vermijl, Marnick defender
Belgium 2012-2015 2
242
Tunnicliffe, Ryan midfielder
England 2012-2014 2
243
Love, Donald defender
Scotland 2016 2
244
Riley, Joe defender
England 2016-2018 2
245
Laird, Ethan defender
England 2017-2023 2
246
Mengi, Teden defender
England 2018-2023 2
247
Gore, Daniel "Dan" midfielder
England 2018-Present* 2
248
Burke, Thomas half-back
Wales 1886-1890 1
249
Howles, Edward half-back
England 1883-1886 1
250
Earp, John right-half/forward
England 1885-1888 1
251
Longton, Aaron half-back/inside-forward
England 1885-1886 1
252
Gotheridge, Isaiah "James" outside-left
England 1884-1889 1
253
Davies, Heber forward
Wales 1883-1888 1
254
Harrison, Charles E. goalkeeper/full-back
England 1887, 1889-1890 1
255
Owen, George inside-left
Wales 1889-1890 1
256
Wilson, Edgar inside-left/outside-left
England 1889-1890 1
257
Ramsey, Robert "Bob" centre-half
Scotland 1890-1891 1
258
Milarvie, Robert outside-left
Scotland 1890-1891 1
259
Felton, Charles half-back
England 1887-1895 1
260
Rattigan, William left-half
England 1890-1893 1
261
O'Shaughnessy, Thomas forward
Wales 1890-1894 1
262
Dale, Herbert half-back
England 1886-1891 1
263
Turner, William centre-forward
England 1890 1
264
Donnelly, John forward
England 1890-1891 1
265
Denman, Joseph right-back
England 1891-1892 1
266
Kinloch, Joseph outside-right
England 1892-1893 1
267
Brady, William inside-right
Scotland 1893 1
268
McFetridge, David left-back
Scotland 1895 1
269
Caine, James goalkeeper/full-back
England 1894-1899 1
270
Longair, William centre-half
Scotland 1895 1
271
Cairns, James outside-left
Scotland 1898 1
272
Owen, William (1898-1899) outside-right
Wales 1898-1899 1
273
Gourlay, James centre-half
Scotland 1899 1
274
Hopkins, James inside-right
England 1899 1
275
Radcliffe, George outside-right
England 1898-1899 1
276
Johnson, Samuel "Sam" inside-forward
England 1901-1902 1
277
O'Brien, George outside-left
England 1902 1
278
Christie, John full-back
Scotland 1902-1904 1
279
Cleaver, Harry forward
England 1902-1903 1
280
Dyer, James forward
England 1905-1908 1
281
Blew, Horace full-back
Wales 1906-1907 1
282
Whiteside, Kerr half-back
Scotland 1908-1910 1
283
Wilson, Thomas Forward
England 1908 1
284
Dalton, Edward full-back
England 1906-1908 1
285
McCarthy, Patrick forward
Wales 1912 1
286
Capper, Alfred forward
England 1911-1913 1
287
Rowe, Jocelyn full-back
England 1914 1
288
Prince, Albert forward
England 1914-1915 1
289
Prentice, John forward
Scotland 1919-1920 1
290
Schofield, George forward
England 1920-1922 1
291
Albinson, George half-back
England 1921-1922 1
292
Schofield, Percy forward
England 1921-1922 1
293
Taylor, Walter Forward
England 1921-1922 1
294
Sarvis, William forward
Wales 1922-1925 1
295
Broome, Albert forward
England 1922-1924 1
296
Tyler, Sidney full-back
England 1922-1924 1
297
Whittle, John Forward
England 1932 1
298
Mitchell, Andrew (1932-1933) forward
England 1932-1933 1
299
Robbie, David forward
Scotland 1935 1
300
Morton, Benjamin forward
England 1935-1936 1
301
Jones, David (1937-1938) half-back
Wales 1937-1938 1
302
McFarlane, William "Noel" forward
Republic of Ireland 1954-1956 1
303
Kennedy, Patrick full-back
Republic of Ireland 1952-1956 1
304
Whitehurst, Walter half-back
England 1955-1956 1
305
Jones, Ernest full-back
England 1957-1960 1
306
Hunter, John "Reg" forward
Wales 1956-1960 1
307
Bratt, Harold half-back
England 1960-1961 1
308
Walker, Dennis Forward
England 1963-1964 1
309
Tranter, Wilfred half-back
England 1962-1966 1
310
Kelly, James midfielder
England 1972-1976 1
311
Clark, Jonathan midfielder
Wales 1975-1978 1
312
Rogers, Martyn defender
England 1977-1979 1
313
Whelan, Anthony defender
Republic of Ireland 1980-1983 1
314
Beardsley, Peter forward
England 1982-1983 1
315
Whitworth, Neal defender
England 1991-1993 1
316
McKee, Colin forward
Scotland 1994 1
317
McGibbon, Pat defender
Northern Ireland 1995-1997 1
318
Notman, Alex forward
Scotland 1998-2001 1
319
Wellens, Richard midfielder
England 1999-2000 1
320
Davis, Jimmy forward
England 1999-2003 1
321
Timm, Mads Forward
Denmark 2002-2006 1
322
Lynch, Mark defender
England 1999-2004 1
323
Johnson, Edward "Eddie" forward
England 2001-2006 1
324
Tierney, Paul midfielder
Republic of Ireland 2000-2005 1
325
Eckersley, Adam defender
England 2005-2007 1
326
Gray, David defender
Scotland 2006-2010 1
327
Marsh, Phil forward
England 2006-2007 1
328
Barnes, Michael forward
England 2006-2008 1
329
Chester, James defender
England 2009-2011 1
330
Cole, Larnell midfielder
England 2011-2014 1
331
Brady, Robbie forward
Republic of Ireland 2012-2013 1
332
Lawrence, Thomas "Tom" forward
Wales 2014 1
333
Janko, Saidy defender
Switzerland 2014-2015 1
334
James, Reece defender
England 2014-2015 1
335
Thorpe, Tom defender
England 2014-2015 1
336
Poole, Reagan defender
Wales 2015-2019 1
337
Weir, James midfielder
England 2011-2016 1
338
Mitchell, Demitri defender
England 2013-2020 1
339
Bernard, Di'Shon defender
Jamaica 2017-2023 1
340
Levitt, Dylan midfielder
Wales 2017-2022 1
341
Bughail-Mellor, Dmani midfielder
England 2017-2022 1
342
Ramazani, Largie forward
Belgium 2017-2020 1
343
Galbraith, Ethan midfielder
Northern Ireland 2017-2023 1
344
Fish, William defender
England 2019-2024 1
345
Savage, Charlie midfielder
Wales 2019-2023 1
346
Iqbal, Zidane midfielder
Iraq 2012-2023 1
347
McNeill, Charlie forward
England 2020-2024 1
348
Dorgu, Patrick wing-back/full-back
Denmark 2025-Present* 1
 

About this site

This site was originally conceived by Mark Graham and launched in 1996. It is the oldest Manchester United website on the internet today and was built to preserve & showcase the history of the club through the sharing of results, statistics & information about Manchester United.
Since its inception, the site has grown considerably with the gargantuan contribution of Roy Redshaw & the immeasurable research efforts of Jim Briggs, Charbel Boujaoude & Rob Compton.
West Cumbria Reds Branch Flag.......as seen behind the Stretford End @ all Home games

 

MUFCINFO.com is not an official Manchester United website.
All pages are designed, maintained and copyright (C) Mark Graham.
Email: mufcinfo@sky.com