Derby County 1
Goal!!!! Commons (30 mins).
 MANCHESTER UNITED 0
 n/a

CARLING CUP SEMI final (1st leg)
Pride Park, Derby, 19.45pm GMT, Wednesday 7th January 2009.
Attendance: 30,194

 Match Review

The Editor of MUFCINFO.COM Article by Mark Graham, Editor, Record Keeper & Official Reporter @ MUFCINFO.COM

A quite brilliant goal from Derby's Kris Commons was more than enough to beat Manchester United in the teams 1st leg semi-final of the Carling Cup, in front newly appointed manager Nigel Clough Derby totally outplayed United & fully deserved their victory.

If current form is anything to go by Son of Old Big heed must be licking his lips in anticipation of managing a team which on this night saw World Champions Manchester United a well beaten team.

SAF had several stars on the field & a strong bench as Kuszczak Rafael, Scholes, Anderson, Gibson, Tevez & Welbeck all started.

United's big gun bench consisted of Rooney, Ronaldo, Carrick, Fletcher & Giggs with youngsters Ben Amos & Rodrigo Possebon.

Derby who at point of kick off had won only once in 9 league games started the fixture like a team possessed with "one night only" manager academy boss David Lowe looking on a proud man Derby rattled United beginning a night to remember for Rams fans.

In the 1st five minutes Davies forced a save from Tomasz Kuszczak and after the fell into his path again United Captain Nemanja Vidic threw himself blocking his dangerous effort.

Barely giving United a moment to breath in a whirlwind first few minutes, Mile Sterjovski had a shot cleared off the line by Jonny Evans, Derby's Andy Todd found the roof of the net after a feeble Kuszczak punch fell at his feet as Derby could smell blood.

As has been the case in a thousand games of football before involving MUFC, a sustained spell of pressure would surely come from the visitors' & chances & possession would be in abundance, however Derby had different plans as SAF's 4-3-3 didn't click all night long due to dogged persistence & a magnificent performance on the Rams behalf.

Unable to any sort of offence going for much of the 1st half Derby took advantage of their form when on the half-hour mark Scottish International Commons ran at United defence as they backed away & with left foot & from 25 yards whizzed a shot past Kuszczak to take the lead.

After pummeling Championship outfit Southampton in the FA Cup the visiting United side were expected to do the same here but something wasn't quite on this night as almost every United player failed to live up to normal expectations.

Feckless in front of the goal in the 1st half United failed to force former Red Roy Carroll into a single save as Derby defended well keeping United out of any sort of passing, attacking rhythm.

With the 1st half gone & one to forget for any United fans, the second wasn't much better either as Derby surprisingly continued to dictate the tempo of the match, with the game wearing on and Derby showing much commitment it would have been correct to say that "burn out" would happen at some point & the Reds would begin to dominate, but not this night, and with only 30 minutes remaining SAF had saw enough & sent on the cavalry.

With 30 minutes left Rooney & Ronaldo were introduced for Scholes & Welbeck as SAF, who at full time expressed his shock at the fact the defeat only added to a one goal deficit rolled his dice hoping to salvage something from the tie.

Briefly sparking United's weak looking attack, Ronaldo shot wide & later went close with a strong free kick which Roy Carroll could only watch rooted to the spot before finally feeling relived Ronaldo's free kick had went wide of the post.

Derby almost took an insurmountable lead to Old Trafford for the second leg as the impressive Commons outclassed Jonny Evans on the right and after releasing a shot at the United goal, Kuszczak spilled the ball into the path of the onrushing Hulse who could be made to rue such an easy miss when the club next meet Jan 20th after inexpiably skiing his shot over the bar from close range.

A very bad day at the office for United with some poor performances but all credit to Derby who played a fantastic game of football.

What's your opinion?.....HAVE YOU'RE SAY BELOW

 Milestones


SAF's 21st League Cup defeat.

JOS's 29th League Cup appearance of his United career.

Cristiano Ronaldo's 260th competitive appearance of his United career.
 SEASON GAMES SUMMARY
GAMES SUMMARY
PLAYED: 33
WON: 20 
DRAWN: 9
LOST: 4 

SCORED: 5
7
CONCEDED: 23

DIFF: +34
CLEAN SHEETS: 20
FAILED TO SCORE: 5

 MUFCINFO's MAN OF THE MATCH


United's Captain battled & blocked some important shots against a spirited Derby side which produced a memorable match winning performance, the pick of a bunch when his troops failed him.
 United's Next Match
Sunday 11th January 2009 v Chelsea (H) in the Premiership, Matchday 19 with a 16.00pm K.O. G.M.T.
Player Ratings
KUSZCZAK
3
RAFAEL
4
EVANS
4.5
VIDIC
6
O'SHEA
4.5
ANDERSON
4
SCHOLES
4
GIBSON
3.5
NANI
3.5
TEVEZ
4
WELBECK
4
Subs Used
ROONEY
5
for Welbeck
(63 mins)
RONALDO
5.5
for Scholes
(63 mins)
CARRICK
5

for Anderson
(74 mins)
 Subs not used
AMOS
GIGGS
FLETCHER
POSSEBON
   

 

       
     

 

West Cumbria Reds Branch Flag.......as seen behind the Stretford End @ all Home games
MUFCINFO.com is not an official Manchester United website.
All pages are designed, maintained and copyright © Mark Graham.
Email: mufcinfo@sky.com